Cookie Monster Ice Cream Recipe

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Warm & Familiar Cookie Monster Ice Cream Recipe

There’s something truly magical about homemade ice cream, especially when it’s as playful and comforting as this Cookie Monster Ice Cream Recipe. I love how the creamy, velvety base wraps around crisp-edged cookie bits, creating a perfect balance of flavors and textures that’s both nostalgic and exciting.

As you scoop into this vibrant blue treat, you’ll notice the inviting aroma of vanilla swirling with the sweet, buttery cookies. Whether you’re sharing it on a sunny afternoon or sneaking bites late at night, this recipe brings a cozy, joyful spirit to your kitchen.

Let’s dive into making this fun dessert together—I promise it’s easier than it looks and absolutely worth every creamy spoonful.

Ingredient Breakdown

• 2 cups Heavy Cream: Creates the rich, buttery mouthfeel. Swap for coconut cream for a smooth dairy-free version.
• 1 cup Milk: Lightens the base and balances creaminess. Almond or oat milk works well for non-dairy needs.
• 3/4 cup Sugar: Sweetens without overpowering. Try a sugar substitute if you want to cut down on sugars.
• 1 tablespoon Vanilla Extract: Adds aromatic warmth and depth. I recommend using real vanilla for the best flavor.
• 2-4 drops Blue Food Coloring: For that signature Cookie Monster hue—start small and build to your favorite shade.
• 1 cup Crushed Chocolate Chip Cookies: Gives crunch and chocolate bursts. Feel free to swap with your favorite cookie.
• 1 cup Crushed Oreo Cookies: Adds creamy cookie sandwich goodness—easy to swap for any sandwich-style cookie.
• Optional Toppings: Whipped cream and mini cookie crumbles amp up festivity and texture.

Before You Start

Gathering your ingredients and setting up your space before diving into making the Cookie Monster Ice Cream Recipe will save you time and keep things joyful. Measure everything out, have your ice cream maker ready, and remember—the blue food coloring is potent, so add it little by little.

How to Make Cookie Monster Ice Cream Recipe

1. Whisk together heavy cream, milk, sugar, and vanilla extract until smooth. I like to use a balloon whisk here; it helps dissolve the sugar fully, so your base is silky without grittiness.
2. Add blue food coloring gradually, whisking until desired hue is achieved. The color makes this recipe so fun—go slow to avoid a too-intense shade.
3. Pour mixture into your ice cream maker and churn for 20-25 minutes until soft-serve consistency. You’ll notice the base thickening, almost like a fluffy cloud forming beneath your whirring blades.
4. In the last 5 minutes of churning, add crushed cookies to the mixture. This last-minute addition keeps cookie pieces delightfully crisp instead of soggy.
🎯

Cook Like a Pro

Adding cookies in the last few minutes preserves their texture and crunch, which is key to recreating that irresistible Cookie Monster experience. Also, ensure your ice cream base is cold before churning—this makes a major difference in texture satisfaction.

5. Transfer ice cream to a freezer-safe container and freeze for 4-6 hours. This resting time firms up the ice cream so it scoops cleanly but stays creamy.
6. Scoop ice cream into bowls and top with whipped cream and mini cookie crumbles. This final touch adds a festive, dreamy bite that’s just irresistible.

Flavor Variations for Cookie Monster Ice Cream Recipe

• Mint Oreo Twist: Swap vanilla for peppermint extract and add chopped mint Oreos for a refreshing pop.
• Peanut Butter Crumble: Stir in mini peanut butter cups along with cookie mix-ins to boost richness and nuttiness.
• Seasonal Spice: Add a pinch of cinnamon or nutmeg to the base for cozy fall vibes.
• Double Chocolate: Mix cacao powder into the base and toss in crushed double chocolate cookies to intensify the chocolate indulgence.
• Fruit & Cookie Combo: Swirl in a handful of crushed freeze-dried berries before freezing for a tart-sweet twist.

Storage, Freezer & Reheat Tips

• Freeze tightly sealed: Use an airtight container to prevent ice crystals and preserve that creamy texture—ideal for up to 2 weeks.
• Thaw briefly before serving: Leave out for 5-10 minutes so scooping is smooth but ice cream remains firm.
• Rechurn for best texture: If your ice cream has hardened unevenly, stirring or briefly blending before serving refreshes the creaminess.
• Keep cookies separate if possible: For longer storage, consider adding cookie mix-ins fresh at serving time to maximize crunch.

Cookie Monster Ice Cream Recipe FAQs

• Can I make this recipe without an ice cream maker? Yes! Pour the mixture into a shallow container and freeze, stirring every 30 minutes until creamy.
• What if I don’t have blue food coloring? You can skip it or use natural blue sources like blueberry juice, but expect a softer color and slight flavor change.
• How do I keep the cookies crunchy? Add cookies toward the end of churning and avoid stirring once fully frozen.
• Can I prep this in advance? Absolutely! The mixture can be refrigerated for up to 24 hours before churning.
• Is there a vegan option? Swap heavy cream and milk for full-fat coconut cream and plant-based milk, and ensure cookie choices are dairy-free.

Print